I am here at Abu Dhabi Airport. My flight was supposed to depart at 2.15am. It’s now 9am and we’ve been told the flight may take off at 11am. So you can imagine the state of the place and the state of me! There’s no point in getting angry at staff, who are trying their best to deal with a mega systems failure. There has been a collapse of the Etihad infrastructure: poor visibility due to fog, lights on the runways have gone out, crews are not able to make their connection and now there is a massive backlog of planes queuing up on the runways with no one to fly them.
Obviously, now that the backlog is into many, many hours, lots of the crew who could work are prevented from doing so as they would be over the acceptable working hours per week or month. Here in the business lounge after 12 hours, it’s like a refugee camp for people with lots of air miles, and the levels of middle-aged male indignation is rising ever higher. The Filipino stewards are doing their best, but they have about as much idea about what is going on as the rest of us. However, their Etihad uniforms makes them legitimate targets for customer ire.
This collapse this morning got me thinking about systems’ failures in general.
Running an airline and an airport that prides itself on being a transit hub is an extremely tricky business and – as everything is profoundly interconnected – when something small goes wrong, like fog in the early morning, everything can collapse. You’d hope that this would not be the case, indeed you convince yourself that this can’t be the case, but it is.
Systems can be very fragile and the difference between smooth organisation and total chaos is, in reality, very small. The possibility of contagion – in this case with flights, connections and crews – is everywhere. Like the ecosystem of a rain forest, each small change can have an amplified effect on activity somewhere further down the food chain.
Deeply unstable set-up
These changes, which on their own don’t seem to add up to much, can profoundly affect the health of some creature or plant. Similarly, the airline network with its web of connecting flights, each one depending on each other, is a deeply unstable set-up.
Financial markets are similarly integrated ecosystems and the question is whether they are becoming more – or less – stable.
It seems fair to suggest that they are becoming much less stable and much more fragile. Each year there are more and more financial crises which have enormous impacts on people’s lives, can overwhelm economies and reduce many millions of people’s ability to make a living. These are real costs, real human costs, and yet the trigger for these crises can be remote and appear inconsequential at first.
In financial markets, confidence can evaporate almost as quickly as it arrived. The reason is leverage. If the entire system is a series of bank-financed IOUs, where borrowed money is speculated on an asset which may yield a bit more cash, then the fortunes of everyone are linked. If a trader in a hedge fund in one part of the world is losing money on his Russian portfolio, and the positions in that portfolio are financed by debt, then he will have to sell something else to pay down that debt.
The difference between the value of a stock and the debt you took out to buy that stock is called the margin. If the value of the stock falls, then the trader is forced to come up with cash to plug the difference between the value of the stock today and the original value of the stock on the day he bought it.
How does he get this cash? Well he has to sell something doesn’t he?
This need for cash is very dangerous because the trader has to sell good assets (which are worth something) to pay for bad assets (which are falling in value). You can see very easily how when there is too much borrowing around, good assets can turn bad very quickly. And more significantly, good assets in one country which may be doing ok, have to be sold to finance bad assets in another country which may be doing badly. There doesn’t need to be any real connection in terms of investment or trade between these countries. The only common denominator needs to be that the same sort of people own the assets in each country. Indeed, it is often the same person.
Debt dynamics
So, for example, as The Sunday Business Post reported, the guy who owns the most Irish government debt, Michael Hasenstab, also owns a big position in Ukrainian government debt.
He is betting that Ukraine – like AIG in 2008- will be deemed ”too big to fail and that ultimately, Russia will extract money from the West to prop up a weakened Ukraine achieving its two geopolitical aims of (1) having a Ukraine firmly in the Russian orbit and (2) getting the West to pay for the pleasure. This is the bond guy’s bet. He bets that the West – the IMF – will use Western taxpayers’ money to pay him what the Ukrainian government owes him. Yet again, we see more and more of other people’s money being passed on to people who had nothing to do with the debts in the first place. What if that doesn’t happen? Then this investor has to sell some of his good stuff to pay for his losses in the Ukraine.
This means he would have to sell some of his peripheral European or other emerging markets debt to pay for his Ukrainian gamble. This means that the debts of emerging markets would fall in value. Where are a significant amount of emerging markets debt held? Why it’s on the balance sheets of European banks, which filled up with this stuff from 2010 to 2012. But this fall in emerging markets debt prices would put a hole in their balance sheets. And what happens then when the ECB stress tests come? The banks with exposure to emerging markets need more capital than previously thought. And thus we can see how bank leverage can lead us into a fresh European banking crisis sparked by an incident over Crimea?
This is how systems break down. As I look out at the rows and rows of grounded Boeings and Airbuses rendered useless because of one small glitch earlier this morning, the nature of system failure comes home to roost.
David McWilliams writes daily on international economics and finance at www.globalmacro360.com
Subscribe to receive my news and articles direct to your inbox
subscribe
Wonder if I’ll beat Adam…. Like Scotland, Ukraine isn’t about economics but about ‘identity’ so the number-crunchers may be in for the mother of all WTFs! This article could usefully be linked to Morgan Kelly’s re-emergence and discussion of a potential debt/stress test tsunami engulfing Ireland once the Draghi Put is debunked by the Bundesbank. Also brings to mind Naseem Tablib’s book “Antifragile” about building resilience into structures/systems to withstand white/grey/black swans. I guess ‘fog’ at an airport is a White Swan: everyone knows it happens so why do folk act like it’s incompetence? Following the leaked EU phone call:… Read more »
Systems and their efficiency are reflective of the culture in which they are developed. While dealing with the “efficiency” of Japan’s banking system may be one of the most frustrating experiences known to man, the efficiency of the country’s train system is truly a wonder of the modern world. Here’s just a small insight:
http://www.realestate-tokyo.com/news/train-delay-certificate/
Fascinating article from Isreal Shamir on the Ukraine Pendulum: “The oligarchs who financed the Maidan operation divided the spoils: the most generous supporter, multi-billionaire Igor “Benya” Kolomoysky, received the great Russian-speaking city of Dnepropetrovsk in fief. He was not required to give up his Israeli passport. His brethren oligarchs took other Russian-speaking industrial cities, including Kharkov and Donetsk, the Ukrainian Chicago or Liverpool. Kolomoysky is not just an ‘oligarch of Jewish origin’: he is an active member of the Jewish community, a supporter of Israel and a donor of many synagogues, one of them the biggest in Europe. He had… Read more »
The conclusion should be that’s it’s long past time to pull the plug on this system and the gangsters who are exploiting it. It’ll of course be painful, but if this is truly the way the financial system & world works, then it isn’t actually delivering value for the community and is not worth propping up.
Hi David, Very good article. Chaos theory is what you are referring to I’d say; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory It will indeed be interesting to see how things pan out. But chaos theory works both ways. If the deleveraging event brings down the derivatives bubbles commodity prices will initially collapse and then sky rocket in a classic cup with handle chart pattern No? The reason I put the last bit in is to convey to all of you that whether you and your family is on the right or wrong side of a black swan event can in many though not all cases… Read more »
Some of this reminds me of the move in business to Just In Time manufacturing. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just_in_time_%28business%29 It is a great concept, the small widgets you need to make your fancy big widget arrive almost when you need to build it. So you don’t need to maintain a backlog of small widgets, which obviously need to be stored, and paid for in advance, which is just too expensive. The reality is that you have removed some if not all the slack from your system, any delay up the chain can ripple wildly. JIT is a valid technique, but it does need… Read more »
“Like the ecosystem of a rain forest, each small change can have an amplified effect on activity somewhere further down the food chain.” not just ‘down’ the food chain tho..thats a bit too Darwinian for me. The Darwinian bottom up model but rather a top down ..we,humanity,and the Biosphere are not governed by such a bottom up process and neither of course is the Universe.The character of the Biosphere is determined by the process of exchange of matter within the environment (“biogenic migration of atoms”)and the subsequent impacts they have on the nature of the “interconnected” Biosphere as a whole,… Read more »
Predictably the mainstream media have poo-pooed Morgan Kelly aka “Doctor Doom!”. Time will tell. I love his turn in his Q&A. “The tyranny of the Weak by the Incompetent. A perfect succinct description of Ireland.” You can tell he obviously has an extremely low opinion of the pixie-heads and seemed to biting his tongue itching to shout “you’re heading for a complete economic and social collapse, you f%*!?#£/ dimwits!!”
My own prediction, the stress-test will be a whitewash, nothing of substance will change, and Crimea will cede to Russia without a whimper from the West.
@douglaskastle As you mentioned in your reply about Just In Time needing to be managed properly or else it would come back and quite literally ‘bite you on the bum’. Well, it’s true. I worked in a company that got into the Just In Time system and what happened was that in quite a few instances the results of doing so did come back to ‘bite them on the bum’. Most of it was just down to inept management at the time, but it happened and in the end management had to change the way they went about operating the… Read more »
Thanks for your article David. Everything in a life is fragile I guess. I hope at this stage you’re on board of a plane to bring you to your next destination.
LOL indeed Georg get a load of this; Anonymous Ukraine releases Klitschko e-mails showing treason Anonymous Ukraine releases Klitschko e-mails showing treason – News – World – The Voice of Russia: News, Breaking news, Politics, Economics, Business, Russia, International current events, Expert opinion, podcasts, Video “Anonymous Ukraine has released the e-mails of one of the leaders of the so called opposition and will continue to expose the moves by the west to subvert the sovereign country of Ukraine. The e mails released by Anonymous prove that Vitaly Klichko is a puppet of the West and is being financed through intermediaries… Read more »
http://voiceofrussia.com/news/2014_02_23/Anonymous-Ukraine-releases-Klitschko-e-mails-showing-treason-3581/
“ECB details criteria for upcoming bank tests”
https://www.rte.ie/news/business/2014/0311/601477-ecb/
Results to be published in October.
Is the following excerpt a long-winded euphemism for a Bail-In?
“”Banks may be expected to correct specific provisions for collectively impaired credit facilities, where the bank’s collective provisioning model is considered as missing crucial aspects required in accounting rules,” the ECB document said.”
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-03-10/was-price-ukraines-liberation-handover-its-gold-fed
Church Board Notice
The 7th Day before the full moon was last week end :
Plane went missing
Earthquake in California
Just keep listening until monday for more revelations
DRIVE SLOWLY
http://usawatchdog.com/
U.S. Definitely Wants War in Ukraine-Paul Craig Roberts
“US is a busted state”
http://www.counterpunch.org/2014/03/13/the-assault-on-gold-2/
The Federal Reserve’s Latest Maneuvers
The Assault on Gold
by PAUL CRAIG ROBERTS