Every now and then you get a chance to work in a place that you’d happily pay to visit. There can be few more stunning places on earth than Interlaken in Switzerland. Therefore, waking up here this morning I could appreciate one of those rare joys in life – someone paying me to come to paradise.
When you look around this place, is it any wonder that the Swiss, with their banking, pharma, high-tech, attention-to-detail, light and heavy industry – not to mention tourism – want to avoid joining the dysfunctional EU?
The Swiss papers this morning are reporting on the European Parliament elections as if they are some sort of quaint ritual in a far-off and rather dysfunctional land. To the Swiss, the notion that you would elect people from your country to sit in a parliament which has no power and no accountability, seems not only illogical, but dangerous.
After all, this is a country where few people care about who is the prime minister. In fact, I’d wager precious few foreigners could name the prime minister of Switzerland. This is because in Switzerland – almost uniquely in the world – power gets weaker and weaker the higher and higher up you go.
It is a country where direct democracy works and is seen to work.
Local is everything, and all the cantons compete against each other to attract business and offer the best standard of living. Taxes are local and financing is local. If there is a national issue that any citizen wants to change, stop or advance, he or she has only to collect 100,000 signatures for a national referendum. This means the little guy can stop anything – or at least the average citizen can be mandated on every major national decision if 100,000 of their fellow citizens feel the same way.
At a time when so many countries are returning nationalist candidates in the European elections – people driven by what Freud described as ‘the narcissism of small differences’ – the Swiss, with their four distinct languages and three major cultures (German, French and Italian), manage to hold it together without hassle. Nationalism between the major ethnic groups is unheard of.
Can you imagine this in Ireland, Scotland or Spain for that matter?
As part of a new quasi-itinerant Irish professional class – a class that finds more work abroad than at home – I find myself comparing countries quite a bit.
Direct democracy as practised in Switzerland is truly interesting, and it appears to work very well. By diminishing the power of big politics, it seems that a country can reduce dramatically the latitude of unwieldy poisonous ideas that lead people up garden paths and ultimately, in extreme cases, pit them against each other.
I have come here from a lecturing stint in Madrid earlier this week, and the contrast between both countries couldn’t be greater.
The political contrast is between the primacy of local politics driven by day-to-day issues, and the primacy of big, national movements which try to bond people with a greater notion of race, religion or language.
In Spain, the nationalists in Catalonia are constantly trying to gain more and more independence and the nationalists in Castile are trying to stop them. In Switzerland, the wind has been taken out of the nationalists’ sails by local politics, so one village can speak Romansh and the next German and no one blinks an eye.
This can only be a good thing when you see what is happening in Ukraine and Scotland, where small differences are elevated to major issues and people are set against each other. Ultimately, this leads to the Balkanisation of people who have much more in common than they are allowed realise. Anyone who has travelled in Croatia, Serbia and Bosnia can attest to the savagery of the ‘narcissism of small differences’.
However, this is not the only difference: money helps, and helps a lot.
For example, economically the first thing that strikes you when comparing Spain and Switzerland is that Spain is cheap and Switzerland is expensive. Spanish unemployment is at 25 per cent, yet last week in Switzerland – where unemployment is virtually zero – there was a vote to introduce the highest minimum wage in the world at €20 an hour. At a macro level, Spain can’t pay its way and has budget and current account deficits; on the other hand, Switzerland runs a perennial current account surplus.
In a crisis, money leaves Spain, and where does it go looking for a home? Yes, to Switzerland of course.
This makes Switzerland richer and Spain poorer and the constant movement of capital reinforces this gap.
Was it the money that allowed Switzerland to run a system of direct democracy, or did direct democracy make the country rich?
Does centralised, big government and power placed in a few hands make countries poorer? Or is it the relative poverty of countries like Spain that drives this type of big politics?
It is a question worth asking in this weekend of elections.
If I were a citizen of Switzerland, I’d stick to the direct democracy model, because it works. They have a lot to lose by doing anything else.
It is amazing that Switzerland can compete with anyone for anything given how expensive the country is. It does so because the people are productive. They are educated and disciplined and, with such a reservoir of capital, capital deployment is rarely a problem. Maybe it is also a function of small governments which only deal with local issues that bind people together.
But enough of this Swissophillia!
Taken together, would I prefer to live in Madrid or Zurich?
Madrid any day. Sometimes, there’s more to life than efficiency!
Subscribe to receive my news and articles direct to your inbox
David McWilliams writes daily on international economics and finance at www.globalmacro360.com
I just voted for Direct Democracy in our Euro elections for all of these reasons. This right to referendum should be a part of any functioning democracy. Why don’t you get behind this movement David if you admire small government so much.
Brehon Law
There was a body of Law in our system before the Common Law overtook our own native system and the power of the people was entrenched inside that .We should revisit this body of knowledge once more and borrow from it and not from the banks.
Having lived in Geneva for five months, during which I travelled quite a bit throughout Switzerland, I can only agree with what David is saying. Switzerland is clean, everything runs of time, it’s safe etc, etc. But it is also very sedate.
I would take Dublin anyday day of the week.
No mention of the dodgy Swiss bank accounts and how they hide all the worst of the worlds money that they got from god knows what evil act, this is why the Swiss have such a good country and can have a minimum wage of 20 euro!, its zip to do with anything else, I am amazed that David did not even mention this fact?….its a no brainer for me.
“Spanish unemployment is at 25 per cent, yet last week in Switzerland – where unemployment is virtually zero – there was a vote to introduce the highest minimum wage in the world at €20 an hour. At a macro level, Spain can’t pay its way and has budget and current account deficits; on the other hand, Switzerland runs a perennial current account surplus” Any chance the head the balls in Fail Eireann could be convinced of the moral of the story in the quote above? During the artificial boom employment labour rates were never more expensive and we had full… Read more »
David’s last two lines say it all – we are Celts/Catholics, not Germanic/Protestants (even their Catholics are ‘protestants’). That is why the rich, sedate, orderly Swiss prefer living in Zurich or Madrid or…shudder, Dublin.
We don’t do direct democracy. Or democracy, for that matter. We do…tribal.
One thing the Direct Democracy people conviently forget to mention about the Swiss example is,while you need 100k worth of signatures to bring a matter to the fore.How many of these petitions since 1872 have been adapted by the Swiss national govts and brought into law?? Answer exactly 12! If you go over to direct democracy Ireland and have a look on their website they have a handy video on how it works in Switzerland. Also , while we might get 100k worth of signatures together here that Enda Kenny should appear in a leather gimp suit along with his… Read more »
Irish Cantons
Pale – Dublin ( greater )
Munster – Thomond – Desmond – Bandon – South Kerry
Connaught – thats it
Ulster – thats it
Leinster – thats it
The islands can be leased to New Scotland .
Limerick City – can form its own Principality and print its own money .
Cork City – same
How did you enjoy meeting Galway’s Guitar heroes Fred and James, David?
You cannot compare Switzerland with the Balkans. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8385069.stm 5 years ago, the native Swiss had a referendum to ban minarets. 700 odd years ago the native Balkans didn’t welcome the idea of minaret construction either, so they had to fight the invading Turks. They sacrificed it with their lives, and lost,and lived under fascist Islam for 500 years. Some natives switched sides later and became Muslim to enjoy favourable taxation policies. These ‘soupers’ descendants then helped the Nazi campaign in WW2, murdering innocent anti-Nazi Serbs. But hey, the media tell us the Serbs are the baddies, and we are reminded… Read more »
COMING SOOOON!!
FIRESALE OF IRISH BEACHES!!!
Curracloe beach in Wexford,Silver Strand in Wickow,Ross Beach-Kilala Mayo,Inchydoney in W.Cork,Dublin’s Dollymount Strand,Ballinskelligs in Kerry,Mullaghmore Beach in Sligo,Stroove in Donegal,,Bunmahon Beach Waterford and Wexford’s Rosslare Strand –
Under the hammer and they’re all going…going …gone,SOLD to The JV of Bank of England and Abdullah ibn Abdilaz?z! [at a 90% discount!]
Check out our suffering comrades in Greece and their David and Goliath battle with the evil asset stripping Troika/IMF
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-05-25/greece-sells-110-beaches-appease-troika-tell-russians-qataris-hurry?page=1
David – Very excellent points are being made by this article.
And hilariously enough, even the French President is now making speeches about less power in Brussels. This is a full 180 degree turn from the “established wisdom” of French Presidents.
Does Singapore need to join the EU ?
The EU has lost the plot. It is intellectually bankrupt. It has become an empire. An empire to end empires. And now there is a need to wind it down. And it does not want to be rolled back.
Decentralization is badly, badly needed.
Singaporeans are only interested in London and the surrounding area aka Engeland. Secondly they like Paris, Switzerland and Austria.
I like meeting people from all over the world and that is why I travell. In all the years I’ve been travelling and from all the people I’ve met I’ve come across three couples from Switzerland and one from Austria. Is there a reason for that?
Could be a coincidence of course. I notice a lot more Belgians travelling lately.
I’m sure I mentioned this before, but just to remind everybody I’ll mention it again. Everything was fine when the EU was just the EEC and since the EEC became the EU everything has gone ‘tits up’. The results from all over the 28 member states just goes to show that the average European citizen doesn’t want more integration they simply want things to return to way things were when we were just the European Economic Community and the sooner this happens the better, for everybody!! The ‘head the balls’ in Brussels should be told in no uncertain terms that… Read more »
N’Espresso Like everything in Switzerland there is a ‘system’ and their coffee success supports that .For anyone to own one or more of their machines they will learn that there is a support to repair/replace the machine any time if it is faulty .Support is always there too to allow anyone anywhere to order the great selections of their wide range of coffees .The system works and it continues to grow . Economics in Ireland is devoid of any system and what most economist believe to be ‘law’ in the country are fakes/ dodos that act as imposters and bleed… Read more »
A bit embarassing to read David’d gushing admiration for Swiss democracy. This is the country that institutionalised offshore banking / tax havens, that happily profited during World Wars 1 and 2 by trading with Germany, and that confiscated Jewish gold after the World War 2. In fact similar to Belgium, another country with a troubled linguistic coexistance, there are severe linguistic strains in Switzerland, with the French and Italian minorities having strong cultural bonds with their fellow speakers across the border. A few years ago when the latest DD referendum on the matter was held, the Swiss French and Italians… Read more »
David never fails to use any excuse to bash the EU, which in this piece he calls “dysfunctional”. The reason Switzerland “works” is because it is tolerated by its EU neighbors, just as the State of Delaware is tolerated by the U.S. Both Switzerland and Delaware exist as pimps to the white collar criminals of larger political groups. In his efforts to bash the EU David argues in this piece at cross purposes with himself. On the one hand he argues against Balkanization by pointing to Croatia, Serbia and Bosnia and the savagery of the “narcissism of small differences”, while… Read more »